Advertisement

The tobacco industry's political efforts to derail the EPA report on ETS

      Abstract

      Abstract

      Previously secret tobacco industry documents detailed a multifaceted approach of political strategies aimed to derail the 1993 Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) risk assessment on environmental tobacco smoke (ETS). These pervasive strategies included the following: (1) lobbying the first Bush Administration to approve an executive order that would impose new risk assessment standards for federal agencies, thus delaying the release of the EPA report; (2) having the first Bush Administration transfer jurisdiction over ETS from the EPA to Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), thus obviating the need for the release of the EPA report; and (3) applying enormous political pressure directly by alleging improper procedure and policy at EPA. Although some of the attempted strategies failed, the political pressure from Congressman Thomas Bliley (R-VA) was a success. This is the first report showing how a single member of Congress in conjunction with his staff, tobacco industry attorneys, and executives worked very aggressively to do the tobacco industry's bidding. These tactics successfully delayed the EPA risk assessment and placed a cloud over its validity that was not fully vindicated until December 2002 when the U.S. 4th Circuit Court of Appeals overturned the tobacco industry's suit against the EPA. The documents show that the industry will expend whatever effort is necessary to protect itself from public health policy that would adversely affect consumption of cigarettes and, therefore, profit.
      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      Purchase one-time access:

      Academic & Personal: 24 hour online accessCorporate R&D Professionals: 24 hour online access
      One-time access price info
      • For academic or personal research use, select 'Academic and Personal'
      • For corporate R&D use, select 'Corporate R&D Professionals'

      Subscribe:

      Subscribe to American Journal of Preventive Medicine
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect

      References

      1. U.S. Department of Health Education and Welfare. Smoking and health: a report of the Surgeon General. Bethesda MD: U.S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare, Public Health Services, Office of the Assistant Secretary for Health, Office on Smoking and Health, 1979. DHEW publication no. (DHS) 79-50066

        • Hirayama T
        Non-smoking wives of heavy smokers have a higher risk of lung cancer.
        BMJ. 1981; 282: 183-185
        • Repace J.L
        • Lowery A.H
        A quantitative estimate of nonsmokers' lung cancer risk from passive smoking.
        Environ Int. 1985; 11: 3-22
      2. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. The health consequences of involuntary smoking: a report of the Surgeon General. Washington DC: Department of Health and Human Services, 1986. DHHS publication no. (CDC) 87-8398

        • Glantz S.A
        • Parmley W.W
        Passive smoking and heart disease. Epidemiology, physiology, and biochemistry.
        Circulation. 1991; 83: 1-12
        • Steenland K
        Passive smoking and the risk of heart disease.
        JAMA. 1992; 267: 94-99
      3. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Respiratory health effects of passive smoking: lung cancer and other disorders. Washington DC: Office of Research and Development, Office of Health and Environmental Assessment, 1992. EPA/600/6-90/006F

        • Hackshaw A.K
        • Law M.R
        • Wald N.J
        The accumulated evidence on lung cancer and environmental tobacco smoke.
        BMJ. 1997; 315: 980-988
      4. National Cancer Institute. Health effects of exposure to environmental tobacco smoke: the report of the California Environmental Protection Agency. Smoking and Tobacco Control Monograph No. 10. Bethesda MD: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, National Institutes of Health, National Cancer Institute, 1999. NIH Pub. No. 99-4645

        • International Agency for Research on Cancer
        Tobacco smoke and involuntary smoking summary of data reported and evaluation, June 2002, Volume 83 http://monographs.iarc.fr/. 2003; (Accessed January 1)
        • National Research Council, National Academy of Sciences
        Environmental tobacco smoke.
        National Academy Press, Washington DC1986
        • Bero L
        • Glantz S.A
        Tobacco industry response to a risk assessment of environmental tobacco smoke.
        Tob Control. 1993; 2: 103-113
      5. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Research and Development, Office of Health and Environmental Assessment. Respiratory health effects of passive smoking (also known as exposure to secondhand smoke or environmental tobacco smoke–ETS). Washington DC: USEPA. EPA/600/6-90/006F, 01 Dec 1992

      6. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Guidelines for Carcinogen Risk Assessment. Washington DC: EPA, (S1 FR 33992) 1986

        • Barnes D
        • Bero L
        Industry-funded research and conflict of interest.
        J Health Polit Policy Law. 1996; 21: 515-542
        • Bero L.A
        • Galbraith A
        • Rennie D
        Sponsored symposia on environmental tobacco smoke.
        JAMA. 1994; 271: 612-617
        • Barnes D
        • Bero L
        Scientific quality on original research articles on environmental tobacco smoke.
        Tob Control. 1997; 6: 19-26
        • Barnes D
        • Bero L
        Why review articles on the health effects of passive smoking reach different conclusions.
        JAMA. 1998; 279: 1566-1570
        • Barnes D.E
        • Hanauer P
        • Slade J
        • Bero L.A
        • Glantz S.A
        Environmental tobacco smoke. The Brown and Williamson documents.
        JAMA. 1995; 274: 248-253
        • Muggli M.E
        • Forster J.L
        • Hurt R.D
        • Repace J.L
        The smoke you don't see.
        Am J Public Health. 2001; 91: 1419-1423
        • Hirschhorn N
        • Bialous S.A
        • Shatenstein S
        Philip Morris' new scientific initiative.
        Tob Control. 2001; 10: 247-252
        • Ong E.K
        • Glantz S.A
        Constructing “sound science” and “good epidemiology:”.
        Am J Public Health. 2001; 91: 1749-1757
        • Samet J.M
        • Burke T.A
        Turning science into junk.
        Am J Public Health. 2001; 91: 1742-1744
        • Hirschhorn N
        • Bialous S.A
        Secondhand smoke and risk assessment.
        Tob Control. 2001; 10: 375-382
        • Drope J
        • Chapman S
        Tobacco industry efforts at discrediting scientific knowledge of environmental tobacco smoke.
        J Epidemiol Community Health. 2001; 55: 588-594
        • Muggli M.E
        • Hurt R.D
        • Blanke D.D
        Science for hire.
        Nicotine Tobacco Res. 2003; 5: 303-314
        • Fields N
        • Chapman S
        Chasing Ernst L Wynder.
        J Epidemiol Community Health. 2003; 57: 571-578
      7. The Tobacco Archives. Available at: http://www.tobaccoarchives.com. Accessed June 2000

      8. Tobacco Documents Online. Available at: http://www.tobaccodocuments.org. Accessed January 2003

      9. Tobacco Control Archives. Available at: http://www.library.ucsf.edu/tobacco. Accessed January 2003

      10. Fuller CL, Linehan K. Presentation for the Board of Directors. June 24, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2047916000-6013 at 6011. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      11. Kessler D. A question of intent: a great American battle with a deadly industry. Public Affairs, NY. 2001

      12. Humber T. ETS. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2023920074-0089 at 0083. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      13. Purcell CC. EPA. April 7, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2023590302-0319 at 0306. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      14. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Hauserman M. April 14, 1983. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 1003478383. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      15. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Reilly W. June 6, 1990. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2026089708-9710. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      16. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Reilly W. June 24, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2026089854-9855. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      17. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Reilly W. December 22, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2047231347-1350. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      18. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Reilly W. May 17, 1990. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2026089705-9707. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      19. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Reilly W. September 18, 1990. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2026089711-9712. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      20. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Reilly W. November 1, 1990. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 20260889713-9717. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      21. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Reilly W. November 23,1990. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2026089718. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      22. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Reilly W. January 30, 1991. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2026089718. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      23. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Reilly W. May 9, 1991. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2023497093. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      24. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Reilly W. December 16, 1991. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2026089719-9732. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      25. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Reilly W. April 2, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2026089883-9897. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      26. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Reilly W. June 10, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2022852181-2182. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      27. Goold J. Fax from Goold J to Parrish S, Thomas K, Ward M. September 14, 1990. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2026090323. Available at: http://www.pmdocs.com

        • Barnoya J
        • Glantz S.A
        Tobacco industry success in preventing regulation of secondhand smoke in Latin America.
        Tob Control. 2002; 11: 305-314
      28. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Lippmann M. May 29, 1991. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2026089733-9739. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      29. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Blot WJ. May 29, 1991. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2026089740-9744. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      30. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Reilly W. November 23, 1990. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2026089716-9717 at 9717. Available at: http://www.pmdocs.com

      31. Kilpatrick J. Invoice. January 8, 1993. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2024329033-9034. Available at: http://www.pmdocs.com

      32. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Reilly W. December 16, 1991. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2026089719-9732 at 9727. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      33. Tobacco Institute. Here's what's now being said about tobacco smoke in the air. August 10, 1981. U.S. Tobacco Institute. TIMN0162316. Available at: http://www.tobaccoinstitute.com

      34. Bliley TJ. Letter from Bliley TJ to Reilly W. April 2, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2026089883-9897 at 9893. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      35. NIOSH. Current Intelligence Bulletin 54. Environmental tobacco smoke in the workplace. Lung cancer and other health effects. Bethesda MD: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Centers for Disease Control, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, 1991

        • Clucas R
        • Gori G
        • Stuntz S
      36. Schlagenhauf J. No title. July 30, 1991. Lorillard Tobacco Company. Bates No. 87207987-7991 at 7986. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

        • Marshall E
        Tobacco science wars.
        Science. 1987; 236: 250-251
      37. Rupp JP. Letter from Rupp J to Schlagenhauf J. July 11, 1990. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2026090062-0068 at 0062. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      38. Schlagenhauf J. No title. July 30, 1991. Lorillard Tobacco Company. Bates No. 87207987-7991 at 7987. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      39. Schlagenhauf J. No title. July 30, 1991. Lorillard Tobacco Company. Bates No. 87207987-7991 at 7990. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      40. Dingell JD, Bliley TJ. Letter to Martin, JC. September 8, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2026090182-0183. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      41. Philip Morris. USA weekly posting ending September 18, 1992. Highlights. September 22, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2055655029-5034 at 5033. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      42. Smoking Policy Institute. February 18, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2026168802. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      43. Boland JE. Executive order. August 5, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2022852158-2160 at 2159. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      44. Dingell JD. Letter from Dingell JD to Reilly WK. April 15, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2023605870-5879 at 5873. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

        • Schlagenhauf J
      45. Fuller CL, Linehan K. Presentation of the Board of Directors. June 24, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2047916000-6013 at 6012. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      46. Borelli T. Executive order/NAM meeting. June 29, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2021520122. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      47. Fuller CL. ETS update. June 12, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2022852176. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      48. Budget 1993 (annual). Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2023585327. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      49. Auchter T. Fax from Auchter T to Parrish S. June 25, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2022852169-2172 at 2170. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      50. Auchter T. Fax from Auchter T to Parrish S. June 25, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2022852169-2172 at 2171. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      51. New project. April 1994. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2046662829-2837 at 2834. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      52. New project. April 1994. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2046662829-2837 at 2833. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      53. Bureau of National Affairs Inc. White House puts risk assessment order on hold, citing election-year conflicts. Washington DC: BNA. 146 DER A-43, 7/29/92

      54. Boland JE. Executive order. August 5, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2022852158-2160 at 2158. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      55. Purcell CC. EPA. April 7, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2023590302-0319 at 0308. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      56. Purcell CC. EPA. April 7, 1992. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2023590302-0319 at 0307. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      57. Appendix of major issues facing Philip Morris. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2023200146-0149 at 0147-0148. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      58. U.S. Department of Labor, Occupational Safety and Health Administration. 29 CFR Parts 1910, 1915, 1926 and 1928 Indoor air quality, proposed rule. Fed Reg 59(65), Tues, April 5, 1994, 15968-16039

      59. ASH Smoking and Health Review. ASH undercut by OSHA; fights worldwide. Vol XXXII, Number 1, Jan-Feb 2002

      60. Humber T. ETS. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2023920074-0089 at 0082. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      61. Parrish S. Environmental tobacco smoke. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2021183691-3692 at 3691. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      62. Wynder EL. Letter from Wynder EL to EPA. September 26, 1990. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2023372474. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      63. Osdene TS. Support of an epidemiologist at AHF. September 24, 1980. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 1003710155. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      64. Osdene TS. Letter from Osdene TS to Wynder E. October 10, 1988. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2021630829. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      65. Osdene TS. Letter from Osdene TS to Seligman RB. April 13, 1981. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 1000129531. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

      66. McVicker RG. Letter from McVicker RG to Wynder E. May 3, 1991. Philip Morris Incorporated. Bates No. 2046988682. Minneapolis: Minnesota Tobacco Document Depository

        • Ong E.K
        • Glantz S.A
        Tobacco industry efforts subverting International Agency for Research on Cancer's second-hand smoke study.
        Lancet. 2000; 355: 1253-1259
        • Yach D
        • Bialous S.A
        Junking science to promote tobacco.
        Am J Public Health. 2001; 91: 1745-1748
      67. Associated Press. Judge's past work as a tobacco lobbyist questioned Asheville Citizen-Times August 20, 1995

      68. Flue-cured tobacco coop. Stabilization Corp v United States EPA, 313 F3d 852 (4th Cir), (2002)

      69. Tobacco company strategies to undermine tobacco control activities at the World Health Organization: report of the committee of experts on tobacco industry documents. July 2000. Available at: http://www.tobacco.who.int/repository/stp58/who_inquiry

        • Malone R.E
        • Balbach E.D
        Tobacco industry documents.
        Tob Control. 2000; 9: 334-338
        • Liberman J
        The shredding of BAT's defense.
        Tob Control. 2002; 11: 271-274