Advertisement

A structured review of the effect of economic incentives on consumers' preventive behavior

      Abstract

      Improving participation in preventive activities will require finding methods to encourage consumers to engage in and remain in such efforts. This review assesses the effects of economic incentives on consumers' preventive health behaviors. A study was classified as complex preventive health if a sustained behavior change was required of the consumer; if it could be accomplished directly (e.g., immunizations), it was considered simple. A systematic literature review identified 111 randomized controlled trials of which 47 (published between 1966 and 2002) met the criteria for review. The economic incentives worked 73% of the time (74% for simple, and 72% for complex). Rates varied by the goal of the incentive. Incentives that increased ability to purchase the preventive service worked better than more diffuse incentives, but the type matters less than the nature of the incentive. Economic incentives are effective in the short run for simple preventive care, and distinct, well-defined behavioral goals. Small incentives can produce finite changes, but it is not clear what size of incentive is needed to yield a major sustained effect.
      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      Purchase one-time access:

      Academic & Personal: 24 hour online accessCorporate R&D Professionals: 24 hour online access
      One-time access price info
      • For academic or personal research use, select 'Academic and Personal'
      • For corporate R&D use, select 'Corporate R&D Professionals'

      Subscribe:

      Subscribe to American Journal of Preventive Medicine
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect

      References

        • Kenkel D.S.
        The demand for preventative medical care.
        Appl Econ. 1994; 26: 313-325
        • Mullahy J.
        It'll only hurt a second? Microeconomic determinants of who gets flu shots.
        Health Econ. 1999; 8: 9-24
        • Cherkin D.C.
        • Grothaus L.
        • Wagner E.H.
        The effect of office visit copayments on preventive care services in an HMO.
        Inquiry. 1990; 27: 24-38
        • Lillard L.
        • Manning W.
        • Peterson C.E.
        • Lurie N.
        • Goldberg G.A.
        • Phelps C.E.
        Preventive medical care: standards, usage, and efficacy.
        Rand Corporation, Santa Monica CA1986
        • Gruber J.
        • Koszegi B.
        Is addiction “rational”? Theory and evidence.
        Q J Econ. 2001; 116: 1261-1303
        • Harris R.P.
        • Helfand M.
        • Woolf S.H
        • et al.
        Current methods of the U.S.
        Am J Prev Med. 2001; 20: 21-35
        • Kahneman D.
        • Tversky A.
        Prospect theory: an analysis of decision under risk.
        Econometrica. 1979; 47: 263-291
        • Johnson P.E.
        • Veazie P.J.
        • Kochevar L
        • et al.
        Understanding variation in chronic disease outcomes.
        Health Care Manag Sci. 2002; 5: 175-189
        • Gigerenzer G.
        Adaptive thinking: rationality in the real world.
        Oxford University Press, New York and Oxford2000
        • Ippolito P.M.
        • Mathios A.D.
        Information, advertising and health choices: a study of the cereal market.
        Rand J Econ. 1990; 21: 459-480
        • Ippolito P.M.
        • Mathios A.D.
        Information and advertising: the case of fat consumption in the United States.
        Am Econ Rev. 1995; 85: 91-95
        • Viscusi W.K.
        Do smokers underestimate risks?.
        J Polit Econ. 1990; 98: 1253-1269
        • Viscusi W.K.
        Age variations in risk perceptions and smoking decisions.
        Rev Econ Stat. 1991; 73: 577-588
        • Viscusi W.K.
        Smoking: making the risky decision.
        Oxford University Press, New York1992
      1. Slovic P. Cigarette smokers: rational actors or rational fools. In: Slovic P, ed. Smoking: risk, perception and public policy. Thousand Oaks CA: Sage, 2001:97–124.

      2. Rieskamp J, Hoffrage U. When do people use simple heuristics, and how can we tell? In: Gigerenzer G, Todd P, ABC Research Group, eds. Simple heuristics that make us smart. New York: Oxford University Press, 1999:141–67.

        • Hellinger F.J.
        The impact of financial incentives on physician behavior in managed care plans: a review of the evidence.
        Med Care Res Rev. 1996; 53: 294-314
      3. U.S. Public Health Service. Healthy people 2000: national health promotion and disease prevention objectives. Washington DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 1991.

      4. U.S. Public Health Service. Healthy people 2010. Washington DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2000.

        • Birkhead G.S.
        • LeBaron C.W.
        • Parsons P
        • et al.
        The immunization of children enrolled in the Special Supplemental Food Program for Women, Infants, and Children (WIC).
        JAMA. 1995; 274 (erratum: JAMA 1995;274:1762): 312-316
        • Dahl D.W.
        • Gorn G.J.
        • Weinberg C.B.
        Encouraging use of coupons to stimulate condom purchase.
        Am J Public Health. 1999; 89: 1866-1869
        • Deren S.
        • Stephens R.
        • Davis W.R
        • et al.
        The impact of providing incentives for attendance at AIDS prevention sessions.
        Public Health Rep. 1994; 109: 548-554
        • Emont S.L.
        • Cummings K.M.
        Using a low-cost, prize-drawing incentive to improve recruitment rate at a work-site smoking cessation clinic.
        J Occup Med. 1992; 34: 771-774
        • Freedman J.D.
        • Mitchell C.K.
        A simple strategy to improve patient adherence to outpatient fecal occult blood testing.
        J Gen Intern Med. 1994; 9: 462-464
        • Hutchins S.S.
        • Rosenthal J.
        • Eason P
        • et al.
        Effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of linking the special supplemental program for women, infants, and children (WIC) and immunization activities.
        J Public Health Policy. 1999; 20: 408-426
        • Kamb M.L.
        • Rhodes F.
        • Hoxworth T
        • et al.
        What about money? Effect of small monetary incentives on enrollment, retention, and motivation to change behaviour in an HIV/STD prevention counselling intervention.
        The Project RESPECT Study Group. Sex Transm Infect. 1998; 74: 253-255
        • Kaplan C.P.
        • Bastani R.
        • Belin T.R
        • et al.
        Improving follow-up after an abnormal pap smear: results from a quasi-experimental intervention study.
        J Womens Health Gend Based Med. 2000; 9: 779-790
        • Kerpelman L.C.
        • Connell D.B.
        • Gunn W.J.
        Effect of a monetary sanction on immunization rates of recipients of aid to families with dependent children.
        JAMA. 2000; 284: 53-59
        • Laken M.P.
        • Ager J.
        Using incentives to increase participation in prenatal care.
        Obstet Gynecol. 1995; 85: 326-329
        • Malotte C.K.
        • Rhodes F.
        • Mais K.E.
        Tuberculosis screening and compliance with return for skin test reading among active drug users.
        Am J Public Health. 1998; 88: 792-796
        • Malotte C.K.
        • Hollingshead J.R.
        • Rhodes F.
        Monetary versus nonmonetary incentives for TB skin test reading among drug users.
        Am J Prev Med. 1999; 16: 182-188
        • Marcus A.C.
        • Crane L.A.
        • Kaplan C.P
        • et al.
        Improving adherence to screening follow-up among women with abnormal Pap smears: results from a large clinic-based trial of three intervention strategies.
        Med Care. 1992; 30: 216-230
        • Marcus A.C.
        • Kaplan C.P.
        • Crane L.A
        • et al.
        Reducing loss-to-follow-up among women with abnormal Pap smears: results from a randomized trial testing an intensive follow-up protocol and economic incentives.
        Med Care. 1998; 36: 397-410
        • Mayer J.A.
        • Clapp E.J.
        • Bartholomew S
        • et al.
        Facility-based inreach strategies to promote annual mammograms.
        Am J Prev Med. 1994; 10: 353-356
        • Mayer J.A.
        • Kellogg M.C.
        Promoting mammography appointment making.
        J Behav Med. 1989; 12: 605-611
        • Melnikow J.
        • Paliescheskey M.
        • Stewart G.K.
        Effect of a transportation incentive on compliance with the first prenatal appointment: a randomized trial.
        Obstet Gynecol. 1997; 89: 1023-1027
        • Moran W.P.
        • Nelson K.
        • Wofford J.L
        • et al.
        Increasing influenza immunization among high-risk patients: education or financial incentive?.
        Am J Med. 1996; 101: 612-620
        • Nexoe J.
        • Kragstrup J.
        • Ronne T.
        Impact of postal invitations and user fee on influenza vaccination rates among the elderly: a randomized controlled trial in general practice.
        Scand J Prim Health Care. 1997; 15: 109-112
        • Owen N.
        • James R.
        • Henrikson D
        • et al.
        Community cholesterol screenings: the impact of follow-up letters and incentives on retest rates and biometric changes in follow-up screenings.
        Am J Health Promotion. 1990; 5: 58-61
        • Satterthwaite P.
        A randomised intervention study to examine the effect on immunisation coverage of making influenza vaccine available at no cost.
        N Z Med J. 1997; 110: 58-60
        • Smith P.B.
        • Weinman M.L.
        • Johnson T.C
        • et al.
        Incentives and their influence on appointment compliance in a teenage family-planning clinic.
        J Adolesc Health Care. 1990; 11: 445-448
        • Stevens-Simon C.
        • O'Connor P.
        • Bassford K.
        Incentives enhance postpartum compliance among adolescent prenatal patients.
        J Adolesc Health. 1994; 15: 396-399
        • Yokley J.M.
        • Glenwick D.S.
        Increasing the immunization of preschool children; an evaluation of applied community interventions.
        J Appl Behav Anal. 1984; 17: 313-325
        • Anderson J.V.
        • Bybee D.I.
        • Brown R.M
        • et al.
        5 a Day fruit and vegetable intervention improves consumption in a low income population.
        J Am Diet Assoc. 2001; 101: 195-202
        • Curry S.J.
        • Wagner E.H.
        • Grothaus L.C.
        Evaluation of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation interventions with a self-help smoking cessation program.
        J Consult Clin Psychol. 1991; 59: 318-324
        • Dey P.
        • Foy R.
        • Woodman M
        • et al.
        Should smoking cessation cost a packet? A pilot randomized controlled trial of the cost-effectiveness of distributing nicotine therapy free of charge.
        Br J Gen Pract. 1999; 49: 127-128
        • Donatelle R.J.
        • Prows S.L.
        • Champeau D
        • et al.
        Randomised controlled trial using social support and financial incentives for high risk pregnant smokers: significant other supporter (SOS) program.
        Tob Control. 2000; 9: 67-69
        • Follick M.J.
        • Fowler J.L.
        • Brown R.A.
        Attrition in worksite weight-loss interventions: the effects of an incentive procedure.
        J Consult Clin Psychol. 1984; 52: 139-140
        • Francisco V.T.
        • Paine A.L.
        • Fawcett S.B
        • et al.
        An experimental evaluation of an incentive program to reduce serum cholesterol levels among health fair participants.
        Arch Fam Med. 1994; 3: 246-251
        • Gomel M.
        • Oldenburg B.
        • Simpson J.M
        • et al.
        Work-site cardiovascular risk reduction: a randomized trial of health risk assessment, education, counseling, and incentives.
        Am J Public Health. 1993; 83: 1231-1238
        • Gottlieb N.H.
        • Nelson A.
        A systematic effort to reduce smoking at the worksite.
        Health Educ Q. 1990; 17: 99-9118
        • Harland J.
        • White M.
        • Drinkwater C
        • et al.
        The Newcastle exercise project: a randomised controlled trial of methods to promote physical activity in primary care.
        BMJ. 1999; 319: 828-832
        • Hughes J.R.
        • Wadland W.C.
        • Fenwick J.W
        • et al.
        Effect of cost on the self-administration and efficacy of nicotine gum: a preliminary study.
        Prev Med. 1991; 20: 486-496
        • Jeffery R.W.
        • Thompson P.D.
        • Wing R.R.
        Effects on weight reduction of strong monetary contracts for calorie restriction or weight loss.
        Behav Res Ther. 1978; 16: 363-369
        • Jeffery R.W.
        • Gerber W.M.
        • Rosenthal B.S
        • et al.
        Monetary contracts in weight control: effectiveness of group and individual contracts of varying size.
        J Consult Clin Psychol. 1983; 51: 242-248
        • Jeffery R.W.
        • Bjornson-Benson W.M.
        • Kurth C.L.
        • Johnson S.L.
        Effectiveness of monetary contracts with two repayment schedules of weight reduction in men and women from self-referred and population samples.
        Behav Ther. 1984; 15: 273-279
        • Jeffery R.W.
        • Forster J.L.
        • Baxter J.E
        • et al.
        An empirical evaluation of the effectiveness of tangible incentives in increasing participation and behavior change in a worksite health promotion program.
        Am J Health Promotion. 1993; 8: 98-9100
        • Jeffery R.W.
        • Forster J.L.
        • French S.A
        • et al.
        The Healthy Worker Project: a work-site intervention for weight control and smoking cessation.
        Am J Public Health. 1993; 83: 395-401
        • Jeffery R.W.
        • Wing R.R.
        • Thorson C
        • et al.
        Use of personal trainers and financial incentives to increase exercise in a behavioral weight-loss program.
        J Consult Clin Psychol. 1998; 66: 777-783
        • Jeffery R.W.
        • French S.A.
        Preventing weight gain in adults: the pound of prevention study.
        Am J Public Health. 1999; 89: 747-751
        • Klesges R.C.
        • Glasgow R.E.
        • Klesges L.M
        • et al.
        Competition and relapse prevention training in worksite smoking modification.
        Health Educ Res. 1987; 2: 5-14
        • Koffman D.M.
        • Lee J.W.
        • Hopp J.W
        • et al.
        The impact of including incentives and competition in a workplace smoking cessation program on quit rates.
        Am J Health Promotion. 1998; 13: 105-111
        • Sciacca J.P.
        • Phipps B.L.
        • Dube D.A
        • et al.
        Influences on breast-feeding by lower-income women: an incentive-based, partner-supported educational program.
        J Am Diet Assoc. 1995; 95: 323-328
        • Stitzer M.L.
        • Bigelow G.E.
        Contingent payment for carbon monoxide reduction: effects of pay amount.
        Behav Ther. 1983; 14: 647-656
        • Windsor R.A.
        • Lowe J.B.
        • Bartlett E.E.
        The effectiveness of a worksite self-help smoking cessation program: a randomized trial.
        J Behav Med. 1988; 11: 407-421
        • Wing R.R.
        • Jeffery R.W.
        • Pronk N
        • et al.
        Effects of a personal trainer and financial incentives on exercise adherence in overweight women in a behavioral weight loss program.
        Obes Res. 1996; 4: 457-462
        • Coffield A.B.
        • Maciosek M.V.
        • McGinnis J.M
        • et al.
        Priorities among recommended clinical preventive services.
        Am J Prev Med. 2001; 21: 1-9
        • Stachnik T.
        • Brown B.
        • Hinds W
        • et al.
        Goal setting, social support and financial incentives in stress management programs: a pilot study of their impact on adherence.
        Am J Health Promotion. 1990; 5: 24-29
        • Deci E.
        • Ryan R.
        Intrinsic motivation and self-determination in human behavior.
        Plenum Press, New York1985
        • Davis M.M.
        • Lantos J.D.
        Ethical considerations in the public policy laboratory.
        JAMA. 2000; 284: 85-87
        • LeBaron C.W.
        • Starnes D.
        • Dini E.F
        • et al.
        The impact of interventions by a community-based organization on inner-city vaccination coverage: Fulton County, Georgia, 1992–1993.
        Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1998; 152: 327-332