Evaluating Health Effects of Transport Interventions

Methodologic Case Study


      There is little evidence about the effects of environmental interventions on population levels of physical activity. Major transport projects may promote or discourage physical activity in the form of walking and cycling, but researching the health effects of such “natural experiments” in transport policy or infrastructure is challenging.


      Case study of attempts in 2004–2005 to evaluate the effects of two major transport projects in Scotland: an urban congestion charging scheme in Edinburgh, and a new urban motorway (freeway) in Glasgow.


      These interventions are typical of many major transport projects. They are unique to their context. They cannot easily be separated from the other components of the wider policies within which they occur. When, where, and how they are implemented are political decisions over which researchers have no control. Baseline data collection required for longitudinal studies may need to be planned before the intervention is certain to take place. There is no simple way of defining a population or area exposed to the intervention or of defining control groups. Changes in quantitative measures of health-related behavior may be difficult to detect.


      Major transport projects have clear potential to influence population health, but it is difficult to define the interventions, categorize exposure, or measure outcomes in ways that are likely to be seen as credible in the field of public health intervention research. A final study design is proposed in which multiple methods and spatial levels of analysis are combined in a longitudinal quasi-experimental study.
      To read this article in full you will need to make a payment

      Purchase one-time access:

      Academic & Personal: 24 hour online accessCorporate R&D Professionals: 24 hour online access
      One-time access price info
      • For academic or personal research use, select 'Academic and Personal'
      • For corporate R&D use, select 'Corporate R&D Professionals'


      Subscribe to American Journal of Preventive Medicine
      Already a print subscriber? Claim online access
      Already an online subscriber? Sign in
      Institutional Access: Sign in to ScienceDirect


        • Evans R.
        • Stoddart G.
        Producing health, consuming health care.
        in: Evans R. Barer M. Marmor T. Why are some people healthy and others not? The determinants of health of populations. Aldine de Gruyter, New York1994: 27-64
        • Hill J.
        • Sallis J.
        • Peters J.
        Economic analysis of eating and physical activity.
        Am J Prev Med. 2004; 27: 111-116
        • Humpel N.
        • Owen N.
        • Leslie E.
        Environmental factors associated with adults’ participation in physical activity.
        Am J Prev Med. 2002; 22: 188-199
        • Owen N.
        • Humpel N.
        • Leslie E.
        • Bauman A.
        • Sallis J.
        Understanding environmental influences on walking.
        Am J Prev Med. 2004; 27: 67-76
        • Hillsdon M.
        • Foster C.
        • Cavill N.
        • Crombie H.
        • Naidoo B.
        The effectiveness of public health interventions for increasing physical activity among adults. Health Development Agency, London2005
        • Nutbeam D.
        Evidence-based public policy for health.
        Promot Educ. 2001; 2: 15-19
        • Wanless D.
        Securing good health for the whole population. HM Treasury, London2004
        • Whitehead M.
        • Petticrew M.
        • Graham H.
        • Macintyre S.
        • Bambra C.
        • Egan M.
        Evidence for public health policy on inequalities. 2. Assembling the evidence jigsaw.
        J Epidemiol Community Health. 2004; 58: 817-821
        • Bauman A.
        The physical environment and physical activity.
        J Epidemiol Community Health. 2005; 59: 535-536
        • Sallis J.
        • Frank L.
        • Saelens B.
        • Kraft M.
        Active transportation and physical activity.
        Transport Res A. 2004; 38: 249-268
        • Dora C.
        • Phillips M.
        Transport, environment and health. World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen2000 (WHO Regional Publications, European Series, 89)
        • Besser L.
        • Dannenberg A.
        Walking to public transit.
        Am J Prev Med. 2005; 29: 273-280
        • Morrison D.
        • Petticrew M.
        • Thomson H.
        What are the most effective ways of improving population health through transport interventions? Evidence from systematic reviews.
        J Epidemiol Community Health. 2003; 57: 327-333
        • Egan M.
        • Petticrew M.
        • Ogilvie D.
        • Hamilton V.
        New roads and human health.
        Am J Public Health. 2003; 93: 1463-1471
        • Ogilvie D.
        • Egan M.
        • Hamilton V.
        • Petticrew M.
        Promoting walking and cycling as an alternative to using cars.
        BMJ. 2004; 329: 763-766
        • Ogilvie D.
        • Egan M.
        • Hamilton V.
        • Petticrew M.
        Systematic reviews of health effects of social interventions. 2. Best available evidence.
        J Epidemiol Community Health. 2005; 59: 886-892
        • Boarnet M.
        • Anderson C.
        • Day K.
        • McMillan T.
        • Alfonzo M.
        Evaluation of the California Safe Routes to School legislation.
        Am J Prev Med. 2005; 28: 134-140
        • Evenson K.
        • Herring A.
        • Huston S.
        Evaluating change in physical activity with the building of a multi-use trail.
        Am J Prev Med. 2005; 28: 177-185
        • Merom D.
        • Bauman A.
        • Vita P.
        • Close G.
        An environmental intervention to promote walking and cycling—the impact of a newly constructed rail trail in western Sydney.
        Prev Med. 2003; 36: 235-242
        • Petticrew M.
        • Cummins S.
        • Ferrell C.
        • et al.
        Natural experiments.
        Public Health. 2005; 119: 751-757
        • Petticrew M.
        • Roberts H.
        Evidence, hierarchies, and typologies.
        J Epidemiol Community Health. 2003; 57: 527-529
        • Green J.
        • Tones K.
        Towards a secure evidence base for health promotion.
        J Public Health Med. 1999; 21: 133-139
        • Thomson H.
        • Hoskins R.
        • Petticrew M.
        • et al.
        Evaluating the health effects of social interventions.
        BMJ. 2004; 328: 282-285
        • Zupan J.
        • Perrotta A.
        An exploration of motor vehicle congestion pricing in New York. Regional Plan Association, New York2003
        • City of Edinburgh Council
        The Integrated Transport Initiative for Edinburgh and south east Scotland.
        Proposed congestion charging scheme. Transport Initiatives Edinburgh Ltd., and City of Edinburgh Council, Edinburgh2004
      1. Scottish Executive Development Department.
        Inquiry into proposed congestion charging scheme. Inquiry Reporters Unit, Scottish Executive Development Department, Edinburgh2004
      2. Scottish Executive. M74 completion: makes complete sense. Available at: Accessed July 11, 2005.

        • Hickman R.
        Roads (Scotland) Act 1984, Acquisition of Land (Authorisation Procedure) (Scotland) Act 1947.
        M74 Special Road (Fullarton Road to west of Kingston Bridge) Orders. Report of public local inquiry into objections. Inquiry Reporters Unit, Scottish Executive, Edinburgh2004
        • Rychetnik L.
        • Frommer M.
        • Hawe P.
        • Shiell A.
        Criteria for evaluating evidence on public health interventions.
        J Epidemiol Community Health. 2002; 56: 119-127
        • Shadish W.
        • Cook T.
        • Campbell D.
        Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for generalized causal inference. Houghton Mifflin, Boston2002
        • Victora C.
        • Habicht J.-P.
        • Bryce J.
        Evidence-based public health.
        Am J Public Health. 2004; 94: 400-405
        • Des Jarlais D.
        • Lyles C.
        • Crepaz N.
        • TREND Group
        Improving the reporting quality of nonrandomized evaluations of behavioral and public health interventions.
        Am J Public Health. 2004; 94: 361-366
        • Booth A.
        • Fry-Smith A.
        Developing the research question.
        in: Topfer L.-A. Auston I. E-text on health technology assessment (HTA) information resources. National Information Center on Health Services Research and Health Care Technology, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda MD2004 (Available at
        • Petticrew M.
        • Roberts H.
        Starting the review.
        in: Systematic reviews in the social sciences a practical guide. Blackwell, Oxford2006: 27-56
        • Goodwin P.
        Solving congestion.
        Inaugural lecture for the Professorship of Transport Policy. University College, London1997
      3. Scottish Executive. The Scottish Health Survey—2003 results. Available at: Accessed January 30, 2006.

        • Jones P.
        • Eyers T.
        • Bray J.
        • et al.
        The Jubilee Line extension impact study. Association for European Transport, London2004 (Proceedings of the European Transport Conference 2004, 4–6 October, Strasbourg, France)
      4. General Register Office for Scotland. Scotland’s census results online. Available at: Accessed July 11, 2005.

        • Øvretveit J.
        Evaluating health interventions. Open University Press, Buckingham1998
        • Wilmink A.
        • Hartman J.
        Evaluation of the Delft bicycle network plan. Ministry of Transport and Public Works, The Hague1987
        • Department for Planning and Infrastructure
        South Perth large scale evaluation report. Department for Planning and Infrastructure, Government of Western Australia, Perth2001
        • Mutrie N.
        • Carney C.
        • Blamey A.
        • Crawford F.
        • Aitchison T.
        • Whitelaw A.
        “Walk in to Work Out”: a randomised controlled trial of a self help intervention to promote active commuting.
        J Epidemiol Community Health. 2002; 56: 407-412
        • Merom D.
        • Miller Y.
        • Lymer S.
        • Bauman A.
        Effect of Australia’s Walk to Work Day campaign on adults’ active commuting and physical activity behavior.
        Am J Health Promot. 2005; 19: 159-162
        • Shephard R.
        Limits to the measurement of habitual physical activity by questionnaires.
        Br J Sports Med. 2003; 37: 197-206
        • Craig C.
        • Marshall A.
        • Sjöström M.
        • et al.
        International physical activity questionnaire.
        Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2003; 35: 1381-1389
        • Rütten A.
        • Ziemainz H.
        • Schena F.
        • et al.
        Using different physical activity measurements in eight European countries. Results of the European Physical Activity Surveillance System (EUPASS) time series survey.
        Public Health Nutr. 2003; 6: 371-376
        • Ryley T.
        Lesson from the Edinburgh congestion charging referendum.
        Traffic Eng Control. 2005; 46: 130-131
      5. Department for Transport.
        Transport statistics bulletin. Stationery Office, London2004
      6. Scottish Executive. Scottish Household Survey travel diary results for 2003: SHS statistical bulletin Trn/2005/2. Available at: Accessed April 21, 2005.

        • Moller J.
        Reconsidering community based interventions.
        Inj Prev. 2004; 10: 2-3
        • Macintyre S.
        • Chalmers I.
        • Horton R.
        • Smith R.
        Using evidence to inform health policy.
        BMJ. 2001; 322: 222-225
        • Davey Smith G.
        • Ebrahim S.
        • Frankel S.
        How policy informs the evidence.
        BMJ. 2001; 322: 184-185
      7. Last J. A dictionary of epidemiology. Oxford University Press, Oxford2001
        • Matt G.
        Will it work in Münster? Meta-analysis and the empirical generalization of causal relationships.
        in: Holling H. Böhning V. Schulze R. Meta-analysis. Springer, Berlin2003: 113-140
        • Hanlon P.
        • Ecob R.
        • Kohli H.
        • Platt S.
        • Whyte B.
        A feasibility study of the potential for compiling a health related database. Scottish Needs Assessment Programme, Glasgow2000